The SWU Report
Image default
ArticleMeta Analysis

The Big Three Lose Their Footing

Before we get into the numbers, a short note. There was no Week 2 article because a longtime gaming friend and my cohost on The White Book (our old AGOT podcast) passed away suddenly, and I wasn’t in a place to write about games. Thank you for your patience while I stepped away. This one is for you, Glazer.

Ok, so Week 3 of Homeworlds is in the books, and it’s the first full week played under FFG’s suspensions of Chimaera, Koska Reeves, Neel, and Aggressive Negotiations. Our cumulative tracked field continues to grow, but those cumulative numbers move slowly, and a slow number is a poor way to catch a sudden change. So this week I’m leaning on two pictures: the cumulative season, and a Week 3 window (the Week 3 pull minus the Week 2 pull). 

What Happened Last Week

Since there was no Week 2 article, here’s the short version of what I would have covered. Sector Qualifier Baltimore (485 players, played November 7) landed alongside a stack of PQs, and it turned into a Hemlock party, with three of the eight Top 8 seats and the trophy going to Doctor Hemlock / Yellow 30. By the end of the week the top three were Wicket / Green Splash, Hemlock / Yellow 30, and Director Krennic / Blue 30, each sitting somewhere between 8% and 11% of the field. Krennic was still the largest and had the best closing numbers among the bigger archetypes (S2-APR of +90.4%). The three played a loose game of rock-paper-scissors, with Wicket beating Krennic, Krennic beating Hemlock, and Wicket and Hemlock a coin flip.

Then on Monday, right after Baltimore, FFG announced suspensions for Chimaera, Koska Reeves, and Neel (all ASH), plus Aggressive Negotiations (SEC), effective November 9. Fourteen of the sixteen Top 8 lists from Utrecht and Baltimore played at least one of them. Hemlock and Krennic each lose Chimaera and Koska Reeves, and Wicket loses Neel and Aggressive Negotiations. I agreed with FFG on Chimaera, Koska Reeves, and Aggressive Negotiations, though I’d push back that Pre Vizsla (which was in more than half of those lists) is still legal.

I’ll admit the timing is awkward for our stats keeping, this early in the Homeworlds period and with Icons right around the corner. The first couple of weeks were played before the suspensions hit, and none of the four cards are leaders or bases, so our archetypes stay the same and I’m going to keep the cumulative baseline running instead of resetting it. Week 3 onward gets flagged as post-suspension. Next up we have Icons arriving shortly, which only leaves a few PQs after the suspensions, so I’ll likely treat them as one short window. Icons will then reset the baselines the way Homeworlds did, with a fresh season tab and Homeworlds’ final standing carried forward as the Week 0 reference, same as we did with ASH. FFG, please let the poor spreadsheet (and my sanity) have one quiet week.

I was also looking at putting predictions out last week, so you’ll have to bear with me that these were my honest takes and aren’t being made now with the benefit of hindsight from this week’s results. The easy take was that Hemlock and Krennic were finished without Chimaera. My hunch was that Hemlock might hold up somewhat, especially if the changes pushed a Vader resurgence, since Hemlock’s Weakness ability is strong against units with 1 health, and I figured Krennic’s S2-APR would be the first number to drop with Chimaera being what stabilized his games. For the scorecard, I expected Lando Calrissian / Blue 30, Darth Vader (JTL) / Yellow 30, Tarfful / Blue 30, and Luke Skywalker (ASH) / Green 30 to climb, and Krennic, Wicket / Green Splash, and Hemlock to slide, with Hemlock sliding the least. We’ll see how that panned out below.

What Happened This Week

The 21 event wins spread across fourteen archetypes, compared to thirteen across eight the week before. Vader (JTL) / Yellow 30 led with three, and Lando / Blue 30, Maul (LOF) / Blue Force, Boba Fett’s Lake Country build, Hemlock / Data Vault, and Vel Sartha / Red 30 took two apiece. Hemlock / Data Vault did it on just five entries, which is a tiny sample, but both of its Top 8 trips ended in a trophy, so I’m keeping an eye on it as well. The names missing from that list matter just as much. Krennic and Hemlock / Yellow 30 won nothing, and neither did Ahsoka Tano in any build.

Cumulative Versus the Window

The cumulative picture says the big three slipped a bit. Krennic is still the largest archetype at 7.7% (down 3.0 points), with Wicket / Green Splash at 7.1% and Hemlock / Yellow 30 at 6.1%, and if that’s all I had, I’d have called it a gentle slide.

Looking at just this week’s window says something much louder, though. In Week 3 alone, Krennic / Blue 30 was 1.8% of the field, Wicket / Green Splash was 2.1%, and Hemlock / Yellow 30 was 1.9%, compared to 10.7%, 9.6%, and 8.2% going into the week. Granted, that’s a window against a season-to-date number, so it isn’t a perfectly fair comparison, but it’s a useful illustration when we’re often just discussing season cumulative figures here. Players want a deck that works without the cards that just left, and from what I’m seeing they voted with their registrations right away. Homeworlds leaders as a group fell from about a third of the field to about a fifth.

The Big Three

Krennic is the clearest case. He put three decks into the window’s Top 8 with no wins, and his game win rate across all builds was 46.8%, the worst of the three. His S2-APR (Top 8 to Win) dropped cumulatively from +90.4% to +55.7%, as I figured it might, though that’s still the best among archetypes with 50 or more entries, with Vader close behind. Krennic wants to ramp into a big turn and snowball from there, and Chimaera was a large part of how he did it and stayed alive. The matchup numbers back that up. Darth Maul (LOF) / Blue Force beat Krennic / Blue 30 fifteen games to four in the window, in a matchup Maul had been losing before the suspensions. That said, it’s probably too soon to call him dead. If the cards people are packing to beat him fade, I could see him turning into a sneaky pick down the road.

Wicket held up better, but it’s two stories now. At the leader level he took the biggest share of the window’s Top 8 slots of any leader, a little over 13%. The Splash build dropped from 9.6% to 2.1% of the field, while Green 30 climbed from 2.0% to 5.8%. Splash builds gave access to things like the explosive Neel into off aspect Han Solo starts, but the archetype as a whole seems to be making a recovery with efficient red and green options still available. Cumulatively, Splash is still the top Top 8 archetype of the season so far.

The straight build has a closing problem of its own, with only one win from fourteen Top 8 slots in the window, and Wicket has predators as well. Green 30 beat Vader about two games out of three, but it lost to both Maul and Talzin (roughly 40% against each), and Lando was an even matchup against Green 30 and a losing one against Splash.

Hemlock is the mixed one. Hemlock / Yellow 30 had four Top 8 slots, no wins, and a game win rate of 44.3%. But the leader as a whole held better than that build suggests, with a game win rate of 55.1% across all builds. Hemlock / Red 30 grew a bit and put six decks into the Top 8, and the Data Vault build won twice. Across all builds, he took a bigger share of the Top 8 slots than of the field. So my hunch going in was half right, since the leader is holding while the Yellow 30 build that carried him through Weeks 1 and 2 took the hit.

Who Moved In

The winners of the shuffle are mostly older sets. Boba Fett (JTL), Lando, and Wicket are effectively tied for the largest leader in the window at about 8% apiece, so I wouldn’t call Wicket the most played deck anymore. Lando more than doubled his share, Boba’s Lake Country build did as well, Maul (LOF) and Mother Talzin (LOF) both put up solid Top 8 numbers, and Vader (JTL) climbed and won three events. Luke Skywalker (ASH) / Green 30 grew the most in relative terms. The easy take is that Lando takes over from here, but with two other leaders sitting right beside him, one post-suspension week is a thin base for a crown.

The bigger story might be the pilot decks. Boba (JTL), Vader (JTL), and both Lukes went from roughly 11% of the cumulative field to roughly 22% in the window, so they about doubled as a group. I think Krennic had a hand in keeping them down, since his early Hyperspace Disaster was a clean answer to pilots, and with him gone they’re back. Han Solo (JTL) / Green 30 is the cautionary tale. His field share more than doubled, but he put only two decks into the Top 8, and he’s still never won an event.

Ahsoka Tano is worth a mention as well. She’s still a big chunk of the cumulative field with no event wins across any build, and as it turns out she was winless again in the window. Both of her main builds sit at the bottom of the Bounty Rating qualifiers. FFG’s worry about aggressive decks taking off quickly may be real, but I still can’t find it in her results.

Scoring the Predictions

Ok, time to see how the scorecard held up against the window. Three of the four climbers did climb. Lando went from 2.9% to 7.3%, Vader from 3.2% to 4.9%, and Luke Skywalker (ASH) / Green 30 from 1.0% to 4.5%. Tarfful / Blue 30 missed, slipping from 2.3% to 1.5%. All three decks I expected to slide did slide, as the window numbers above show.

The Hemlock part of my call only half works. By points lost, Hemlock / Yellow 30 slid the least of the three, but only by a narrow margin, and at the leader level Wicket slid less than Hemlock did, so I’ll call that a partial. The Vader resurgence, on the other hand, is a hit.

Meta Health and Bounty Rating

Cumulative Field HHI reads Open at 2.9 (down from 4.0), and Top 8 HHI fell from a Healthy 6.4 to an Open 3.5, the first time it’s landed in the Open band this season. As a whole, I’m happy to say the top of the board has spread out, which is what a healthy format should look like after losing some of its best cards.

Twelve archetypes now clear the Bounty Rating sample floor (50 or more in the field and 3 or more Top 8s), up from five last week. Wicket / Green Splash still leads at 81.8, followed by Krennic, and Vader (JTL) / Yellow 30 made the biggest jump, from 47.4 to 68.0. Bounty Rating is cumulative, so the top of the list is still carrying Week 1 and Week 2 results, and I’d expect that order to get shuffled over the next few weeks if the window trend holds.

What I’m Tracking Next

I’ve got three questions going into Week 4. First, do Krennic and Hemlock / Yellow 30 stabilize near these shares or keep falling? A deck that nobody plays can’t win anything, but a deck that only the committed players are bringing might surprise us. Second, does Wicket / Green 30 learn how to finish? It keeps reaching the Top 8 and stalling at the last step, which is the same pattern Hemlock showed in Week 2. Third, is Vader’s window real or a small-sample spike? His cumulative S2-APR of +50.2% says he can close, but one week of Top 8s isn’t a lot to hang a conclusion on. He also won only about a third of his games against Wicket, and that’s a rough matchup to carry against a deck this popular. My hunch is that his share rises again next week while his results cool off, since a deck like him tends to get remembered once it starts winning. That one goes on the scorecard, and we’ll check on it more next week.

Looking Ahead

So where does this leave us? We’ve got a format that spread out almost overnight, a former top three that lost much of its audience, and a pile of older leaders reclaiming space as players look for decks that don’t lean on the suspended cards. The big question for Week 4 is whether any one deck steps into the hole at the top, or whether this stays wide open until Icons shows up.

That’s all for now.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Secret Link
0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x